Content-Type: text/html From: "Larry Lyons" <[log in to unmask]> 12:29 AM >From: > "Richard H. Armstrong" <[log in to unmask]> > >2:03 AM > > >Larry, > > From a practical standpoint (if you will forgive me for saying that), >drowning is a good way to kill someone you love, since it doesn't >involve the shedding of blood and all the moral and literal >defilement that entails. Not long ago, people still used to drown >whole litters of kittens, and some probably still do. It's harder >work than shooting them, but it leaves a nicer corpse. > >The water/womb connection is also very strong and obvious, but as I >am not an analyst, I'll let others spin that out. I know of no >consensus, however. > Richard Hello Richard: What you are suggesting is that mothers who drown their children might make rational decisions as to the method they will use to kill the people they love. Of course you are right. Only an incredibly stupid detective would fail to consider alternate possibilities--especially in trying to figure out a psychological profile. However, there is enough peculiarity in the problem we are discussing to arouse the suspicions of the most mediocre detective. We have loads of evidence that dreams are disguised fulfillment of suppressed wishes. We have evidence that psychotic acts are disguised fulfillment of suppressed wishes. We have evidence that women's impulses to drown their children are psychotic in origin. We have evidence that dreams of drowned children are widespread among normal women. In addition, we are aware that women seldom kill their children, but when they do, it is often by drowning. Also we are aware that men who are NOT psychotic are much more likely to kill their children, or any other person they love, than are psychotic women. Also, we are aware that men who kill their beloved, whether that belovedis a child or adult, seldom, if ever, drown them, but are very likely to shoot, stab, strangle, burn, suffocate or beat their loved ones to death. Yours, Larry D. Lyons [log in to unmask] _________________________________________________________________ Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com